Thursday, December 18, 2008

Eight Books From '08

Well another year of reading down and now this is my second annual book recommendation post. I love reading a good book and recommendations of a good book. So if you have one to recommend leave it in the comments. Here are my favorites from the year:

8.Massacre at Mountain Meadows

In 1857 a group of 120 men women and children were massacred by Mormon settlers and to a lesser extent a Native American tribe in Southern Utah. Many books have been written on this subject recently, mostly with a polemical bent of one kind or another. This three hundred page book deals only with the events leading up to the Massacre, and not the aftermath. It is not apologetic and is a somber and sad account. I spent every page hoping the tragedy would not happen, that those trying to prevent it and those in authority in Cedar City would stop the events from escalating. I was fascinated with the ingredients that combined and the lessons can be drawn from this event. Three Mormon historians wrote this account after combing the LDS archives and included information that has not been published before. This book is not for everyone. If you like Western or American history or are intrigued by this event, this is a concise account that offers the most up to date account of what happened.



When I went to Monticello with my brother-in-law, Branagan, last year, we went on a slavery focused tour of Jefferson's former residence. The park service had recreated the sheds his slaves lived in and showed us broken bits of plates, tools, and trinkets they had found from an archaeological dig. We were told about Jefferson's mistress, her brother whom he took to Paris to learn cooking, and other slaves and what their lives were like. The tour was fascinating and so I wanted to read more. This book recounts the history of the Hemings family and their relation to Jefferson and spends a great amount of time postulating about Jefferson's relationship and children with Sally. The author is at a great disadvantage because the lives and feelings of most of his slaves passed away without being recorded. A lot of these pages are speculative and I feel like the book could be condensed, but a good read. I think you need to couple this book with a founding fathers or laudatory Jefferson type biography so you can learn more about the strengths and positive contributions of Jefferson in addition to his shortcomings.

6.The Bin Ladens

My father-in-law gave this to me as a gift and it is a quick and informative read. It tells the story of how the Bin Ladens came to be one of the wealthiest families in Saudi Arabia and how their son turned to the dark side. A great book to understand current events and get a peek into a Middle Eastern culture and the interface between our world and theirs.

5.The Dark Side
In response to September 11th, the White House and Congress began to rethink many of its policies in regards to war and terror. As the pursuit of terrorist was ratcheted up, policies and laws that were in place were disregarded and questioned in the pursuit of Al Qaeda. What is torture, extreme rendition, the rights of those accused and those not accused? Does torture work and when is it allowed? What gives America the moral high ground? This book is well documented and explores these vital questions with specific examples. Though it does have a left leaning tint, its well written, researched, and documented and is not just another anti-Bush book.

4.Frankenstein

I try every once in a while to read a book of fiction that I should have read already but haven't yet. Last year it was Moby Dick. This year it was Frankenstein. This is a book you can read in one sitting and it is actually a pretty good read. The passionate chase between creator and monster and the memorable quotes by the monster such as "You are my creator, but I am your master;-Obey." and "I am malicious because I am miserable" make this book live up to its fiendish reputation.

3.Unaccustomed Earth

A collection of short stories, often morose of Indian transplants and their descendants trying to adjust to life in the western world. This author wrote the Namesake, which was made into a slow but great film. I read very little current fiction and am very picky in this department, but enjoyed this book. I admire the authors prose and ability to document life in a literary way. My favorite story is about Rahul, the alcoholic brother who comes back into his sisters life and the Sisters ambivalence about the part she played and will play as he returns. Her short stories that are pretty gripping and great for someone with a low fiction tolerance, like me.

2.Ghost Hunters: William James and the Search for Scientific Proof of Life After Death

This is a fun book. Around the turn of the century, before the study of the paranormal was pushed to the fringe, mainstream scientist were trying to settle the questions of the soul and afterlife through the scientific method. The author narrates spooky events. Prominent scientists going to seances, documenting deceased people appearing and peoples ability to sense that a love one has passed away that is away. One scientist tries to figure out why someone weighs less the moment after they die. Though ultimately scientists moved on to other fields of study after this, it's fun to learn about academia and general spiritual beliefs in the late eighteen hundreds.

1.The Nine (By Jeffrey Toobin)
I love books where I can learn about a subject I don't know much about and wouldn't be able to tolerate in another form. I guess what I'm saying is I love an author who can explain and introduce a world that was before foreign or difficult for me. I'm no lawyer. I get bored reading about the law even though I know its important. This book translates the highest court's personalities and desicions to non-lawyer types such as myself. How should the law be interpreted and how do the characters of all the justices interact and affect the law? What direction is the court headed and where is it going? For a guy like me (and perhaps Governor Palin) who can't name many court cases, this is an excellent and remarkably breezy introduction to the recent history of the supreme court. The profiles of the justices are fascinating. The book really is written to inform more than a pulpit for the author to say who is right or wrong or what should happen. This book is great and I recommend it to all.



-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

1.Note On rereading:
I try to re-read some Flannery O Connor each year, so that doesn't count as a new book this year. I recommend her fiction to all. She's my favorite fiction writer. I reread Wise Blood and it was funny and intelligent and on message as I remember it. Also we podcasted Jesus The Christ which is great to listen to when driving. I reread Rough Stone Rolling which is a great read if you are in to LDS Church History and studying the life of Joseph Smith.

2. Here is a list of 2008 books I got through and took my favorites from:

4 comments:

Anonymous said...

You asked for a thoughtful post. Here is what you get.

The books I read this year were not many. If you include the pages read in work-related material, I probably out read any family of five in this country. It's been the same story over the last four years and I have had to become somewhat of a book snob. I check out hundreds of books a year from the library and know within minutes if it is something that I will read. Some books get the snub for no reason — the author picked the wrong first sentence being my favorite un-reason for putting down a book. The point is that I have to be selective; I wish I didn't. Maybe I will finish my exams before the affect is permanent.

I set a goal in January to read a biography of each of the Presidents of the United States in order, from one to forty-three. Of course, that would only require forty-two books, but I got hung up in February on book number three — Fawn Brodie's autobiography of Thomas Jefferson

After reading “His Excellency” (about G. Washington) and “John Adams” by David McCullough I was completely skeptical of any biography that would paint Jefferson with a positive slant. Knowing how controversial Brodie's bio of the Prophet Joseph Smith is, I thought that I could gain some respect for Jefferson by feeling to side with him against a biased biographer. Unfortunately, I encountered the absolute worst writing that I have ever read or tried to read.

There are sins in writing that are nearly ubiquitous. Grammatical errors, spelling, and agreement problems readily come to mind in this age where everyone is published in some form or another. But, her sin was worse. She committed pre-meditated murder while the rest of us are occasionally guilty of being insensitive. I will spare your readers the gory (and titillating) details. Besides, it is better to use the book as a measure of one's ability to read critically. Be wary of anyone who reads this book and did not stop somewhere around page one hundred.

What is interesting is that you won't find a discussion of her error in any review of the work. And, just one clue to those of you who go looking, it is not something she wrote that made me upset, but something that she intentionally omitted.

I tried two or three other biographies of Jefferson but didn't get much out of any. In the forgettable ones he was too praised or the author got the first sentence wrong. Ellis's “American Sphinx” had a promising beginning but he fell into the habit of seeking for a unifying template to which the actions of Jefferson's life could all be laboriously made to fit. He tried to explain Jefferson in an unnatural way; a way in which a politician or the institutionalized might find a unifying theme to every decision they ever made.

Although I gave up on Jefferson, and by definition, my goal of presidential biographies, I did not give up on reading. I read Huck Finn again this year. That was a good experience. I also read my first piece of conservative propaganda, Who Killed the Constitution. That lead to other works of conservative literature which I now know how to read without getting too angry or depressed.

Next year, I will continue with the Presidents. Jefferson is still going to take some work, but I think that the “Hemingses of Monticello” can be made to fulfill the requirement.

Thank you for the recommendations. Cheers to another year of good reading.

Adam

unemployed one said...

as a lover of fiction, your list was hard for me to jump into but i am very proud of you for your choice of the unaccustomed earth. adored that book; along with the namesake and her pulitzer prize winning interpreter of maladies.

Wendy said...

Very interesting recommendations, Bird. So, I'm still reading President McKay's biography, after two years. Finished reading Chocolate by Mort Rosenblum, after having it on my nightstand for three years. Read A LOT of Junie B Jones and Dr. Suess to Alexander, and read school newsletters and fitness and health literature. So, there's my recommendation: to read more than I did this year!

Renee said...

Great list!! As a non-lover of non-fiction, you've given me some good recommendations to give it a go again. I'm particularly interested in the Hemingses of Monticello and The Nine! I still always have on my list to read Rough Stone Rolling...we'll see if I tackle it this year :)